BullOrBSBullOrBS
10

All Roasts

10 recommendation audits

ROASTCVXMar 13, 2026

Chevron (CVX): Strong Dividend & Recent Rally, But Valuation and Payout Ratio Are Screaming Red Flags

Chevron is trading at $196.97 after a 24.6% YTD run, boosted by oil prices spiking above $75–$100 due to Iran-US tensions. The company offers a 3.6% dividend yield with 39 years of increases, but its payout ratio has ballooned to 104%—meaning it's paying out more than it earns—and the current valuation looks stretched at 28.7x trailing earnings.

Current Stock Price:$196.97

Read full analysis →

ROASTADOBEMar 13, 2026

Adobe Gets Hammered on CEO Exit—But Is the Selloff Overdone?

Adobe beat Q1 earnings estimates but the stock tanked 8% after CEO Shantanu Narayen announced his departure with no successor named. The data shows a cheap valuation and strong cash generation, but leadership chaos and AI competition create real near-term risk.

Current Stock Price:$247.83 (down ~8% from prior close on Mar 13 intraday)

Read full analysis →

ROASTORCLMar 11, 2026

Oracle Stock Surges 10% on Earnings Beat, But Red Flags Are Piling Up

Oracle just reported strong Q3 earnings with cloud revenue growing 44% and management raising the full-year outlook. The stock jumped ~10% in pre-market trading. But there's a catch: the company is burning cash, drowning in debt, and facing a securities fraud lawsuit. Is this a growth story or a value trap?

Stock Price (close, March 10, 2026):$149.40

Read full analysis →

ROASTSU.TOMar 10, 2026

Suncor Energy: A Dividend Play or an Oil Trap?

Suncor (SU.TO) hit record production in Q4 2025 and trades at a 15.98 P/E with a 3.09% dividend yield. The company returned C$5.8B to shareholders in 2025 and plans C$3.3B in buybacks for 2026. But most analyst price targets sit 10% below the current C$77.50 price, and one major analyst downgraded to Sell in February.

Current Price (TSX, Mar 10, 2026):C$77.50

Read full analysis →

ROASTCSU.TOMar 10, 2026

Constellation Software's Historic Drawdown: Generational Bargain or AI Casualty?

Constellation Software (CSU.TO) has fallen ~44% from its C$5,300 ATH to ~C$2,944 (and as much as 59% at its 52-week low of C$2,196) on fears that AI-driven code generation will kill its vertical market software moat. The data tells a split story: operational cash flows hit records (up 24% to US$2.7B), but net income dropped 30% YoY — though the Asseco Poland charge fully explains the decline. Is the market pricing existential risk fairly, or panicking?

Current Price:C$2,944

Read full analysis →

ROASTOTEXMar 8, 2026

OpenText: Hidden Gem or Overcooked Acquisition Play?

OpenText has legitimate strengths in enterprise software, but the 'hidden gem' framing ignores declining revenue, sub-1% ARR growth, and an aggressive M&A strategy that's now shedding assets. With FY2025 revenue down 10% and quarterly ARR growing just 0.7%, the AI upside is speculative and the numbers tell a different story than the hype.

Q2 FY2026 Revenue:$1.33B (-0.6% YoY)

Read full analysis →

ROASTRYMar 8, 2026

RY's 3.8% Yield? Try 2.9%. This 'Buy Forever' Call Starts With a Math Error.

The newsletter's core claim is factually wrong—Royal Bank's dividend yield is 2.9%, not 3.8%, per March 2026 data. While RBC remains a quality bank with record Q1 earnings and a solid track record, it's trading at a premium valuation (P/E of 16.1x vs. sector average of 12.8x) and offers the *lowest* dividend yield among Big 5 Canadian banks. Bank of Nova Scotia delivers ~4.3% yield at better value, while National Bank offers superior growth. The recommendation isn't terrible, but it's lazy—ignoring superior alternatives and starting with incorrect data.

Actual Dividend Yield:2.92% (CAD), 2.78% (USD)

Read full analysis →

ROASTSHOPMar 8, 2026

The $132 Stock Trading at 138x Earnings: Is Shopify's 'Explosive Growth' Just Expensive Hype?

Shopify delivered impressive 30% revenue growth and strong merchant momentum in 2025, but the stock's 138x trailing P/E and recent 28% drop from highs raise serious questions. While merchant solutions are indeed accelerating and international revenue grew 36%, investors are paying a steep premium for growth that's decelerating from pandemic peaks—and ignoring cheaper alternatives.

Current Stock Price:$132.16 (March 10, 2026)

Read full analysis →

ROASTTSLAMar 8, 2026

Tesla as an AI/Autonomous Driving Play: Hype Outpaces Evidence

The recommendation to buy Tesla as a 'strong AI play' rests on a real strength (autonomous driving R&D) but overstates conviction without concrete proof of market dominance. At 369x trailing earnings with declining revenue growth, the bull case is sound but generic—and the valuation already prices in this upside.

Market Cap:$1.50 trillion

Read full analysis →

ROASTSHOPMar 6, 2026

They Said Buy Shopify at $177. The AI Ran the Numbers.

A popular financial publication recommended Shopify as a top Canadian tech stock. We audited the recommendation with data. Here's what they missed.

Price (CAD):~$177

Read full analysis →

MORE:All Picks →All News →